Getty Adam Maida / The Atlantic

Billie Eilish has some scary issues, she tells listeners on her new album’s first tune, “Getting Older.” A stranger outside the house her door is performing deranged. Loneliness and burnout mount in her thoughts. Abuse and trauma darken her earlier. She murmurs about these items around a synthesizer that pulses like a time bomb. It hardly ever looks to explode, but the last verse does include a shock.

“For any individual inquiring,” Eilish sings, “I promise I’ll be good.”

Wonderful has not often been Eilish’s detail. Her 2019 debut, When We All Fall Asleep, Where by Do We Go?, swept the major Grammy classes and marketed thousands and thousands of copies with cleverly created tales of feeling not okay. Monsters, the apocalypse, and suicide swirled in her thoughts—and the drama of the tracks lay in the sense that she could, in some dreadful switch, slide target to the points that terrorized her. At the climax of the album’s runtime, she sang a farewell from the edge of a constructing. The tune, “Listen Right before I Go,” faded out in a din of sirens.

Talking openly about melancholy and self-damage, the now-19-calendar year-outdated Eilish became a potent mascot for a technology of young Americans who are, in accordance to scientific tests, extraordinarily unhappy. Her success also capped off a ten years in the course of which well known music created much more area for malaise in its melodies. The influence of Drake, that self-doubting celebrity, permeated Eilish’s shadowy, rap-inflected audio. But she also joined a lineage coded together gender (and, a lot more subtly, racial) lines. She was a Sad Girl™, setting up explicitly on the 2010s’ most vital whispering divas, Lorde and Lana Del Rey.

All three women of all ages have introduced new audio this year, and all three seem to be to be scraping off the unhappy tag. Lorde’s one “Solar Power” is a strummed summertime gust. Lana Del Rey’s March album, Chemtrails Above the Country Club, meditates on character, local community, and contentment. Eilish telegraphs a swerve with her album’s title, Happier Than Ever, and its connected visuals: blond locks and creamy hues in its place of goth greens and blacks. But hear to all this music and gauge the reactions to it, and you still simply cannot rather make the circumstance that our tradition is perking up. In this summer season of uneasy celebration, some of pop’s most considerate girls are displaying that pleasure—for themselves, for other girls, for everyone—is everything but uncomplicated.

The joke embedded in the rollout for Eilish’s Happier Than Ever is that it’s substantially much less joyful to pay attention to than When We All Drop Asleep, Exactly where Do We Go? That debut had a type of Nightmare In advance of Christmas playfulness to it, with shuffling rhythms and foolish sound consequences augmenting the haunted sing-alongs. The comply with-up—created all over again by Eilish and her multi-instrumentalist brother, Finneas O’Connell—is muted, chilly, and controlled. It contains quite a few of the exact same ingredients as right before, but they’re made use of in sparing proportions to produce subtler and—in the best moments—richer payoffs.

This sort of restraint, we’re meant to sense, demonstrates tough-received self-assurance. Eilish’s first brush with fame horrified her, according to push interviews and footage in her 2021 tour documentary, The World’s a Very little Blurry. Shedding privacy and independence—and attaining judgmental audiences, sector pressures, and a grueling schedule—made her would like she’d under no circumstances blown up. But with treatment and age (“like the true substances in my brain shifting,” she told the Los Angeles Moments), she got far better. “I fucking appreciate fame,” she stated on a podcast this yr.

Happier Than Ever is not definitely about this psychological journey. In its place it is a speech from the best of a mountain, directed downward—at grasping enthusiasts, prying reporters, crappy exes, and exploitative energy brokers, all of whom she insists hassle her less now. Appropriately, the album’s delicacies are dis tracks, which emphasize Eilish’s oddly Broadway-ish knack as a performer-storyteller. Each interlocking line of lyric builds a kind of sensible momentum her variegated deadpan is so fully commited that it should truly be considered hammy. O’Connell’s ear-catching still understated production—skeletal reggae with dog snarls on “I Did not Improve My Range,” a charmingly lazy bass line on “Missing Induce”—helps her blows land cleanly.

Eilish’s supposedly peaceful interior sanctum, the self unbiased of many others, stays gated. When she expresses motivation, as on the chaotic bop “Oxytocin,” imaginary audiences intrude: “What would persons say … if they listen via the wall?” When she thinks about mortality, the thought that disturbed the narrator of When We All Drop Asleep, she becomes blasé: “Everybody Dies” spends 3 minutes and 26 seconds calmly conveying its have title. The direct single, “My Future,” flies into jazzland as Eilish goals about the years ahead—while also holding back particulars of her hopes. You get the perception that she feels protecting of her own satisfaction, and that singing about it would make her additional vulnerable than any bleak confession would. Genuinely, she has excellent rationale to come to feel that way.

Pleasure, of class, is one particular of pop’s core substances: Katy Perry yelped about it in “Teenage Dream” and DJ Khaled exudes it each and every time he bellows his identify. Nonetheless Eilish exemplifies a strand of new music that emerged to obstacle the shiny, empowering silliness that ruled the charts a decade in the past. “I’m kind of above gettin’ told to toss my palms up in the air” sang Lorde, then 16 yrs outdated, on her 2013 album, Pure Heroine, whose breakout strike mocked pop’s clichés of accomplishment: “gold teeth, Gray Goose, trippin’ in the toilet.” Lorde was touting a “new art sort, showin’ folks how tiny we care,” and millions tuned in.

Even though Lorde would regularly be termed “sad,” it’s well worth noting that a major chunk of her catalog is about joy—the intimate, unsurveilled joy of a pleasant night time in a suburban bedroom, or of a lady dancing by itself. Her revolution was, additional than anything, sonic: blue-y, ambivalent chords textured, worn singing eerily stacked track record vocals entice drums repurposed to experience like a songwriter’s heartbeat. These capabilities became ubiquitous in mid-2010s pop, with her imitators filling Spotify playlists and 50 Shades of Grey soundtracks. But Lorde kept herself rather scarce, releasing only a person subsequent album until now (it is slated for later on this month).

In the course of substantially of that same period, the influential voice of Lana Del Rey also wafted as a result of well known tradition like a fog. Her 2011 single “Video Games” announced her template: languid, reverberating lounge singing about girls sacrificing by themselves for hot, callous adult males. Daring sonic choices—brazen rap appropriation, colossal rock preparations, soppy soundtrack orchestras—and jarringly precise lyrics held this system clean around a regular stream of albums and smaller controversies. In addition to her musical genius, her persona mattered too: Del Rey was pop culture’s head unfortunate girl.

The significantly-talked about archetype of the sad girl is not just a musical category—it has pervaded manner, Television, and, most noticeably, social-media platforms these types of as Tumblr and TikTok. In a 2014 Pitchfork essay, Lindsay Zoladz argued that it was liberating for girls to buck anticipations “to be warmly smiling Stepford Wives emanating sunbeams from their each and every pore.” Other essayists, this sort of as Sydney Gore at The Toast, positioned the unhappy woman as element of a broader go toward vulnerability—just one particular signal of the destigmatization of mental-overall health discussions. (Absolutely sure enough, a crop of unfortunate boys emerged in the 2010s as effectively.)

But disappointment can turn out to be a restricting stereotype as well. In a tweet this calendar year, the singer Lucy Dacus rejected the label “sad lady indie”—because her songs weren’t unfortunate, and because of the “commodification and perpetual expectation of women’s suffering.” Without a doubt, most “sad girl” music expresses elaborate thoughts, and the community fascination with teary-eyed women of all ages can seem to be sadistic. “I ain’t no candle in the wind,” Del Rey sang on a 2018 song the reference to Marilyn Monroe and Princess Diana seemed to force back again at individuals who projected tragedy onto the singer. The mind-boggling whiteness of celebs labeled “sad girls” appears to be telling way too. Just one just can’t enable wonder if they are from time to time fetishized for resembling aged, identification-certain caricatures of helplessness and fragility: In this article is a further princess-like Ophelia, wrecked by want, and all the extra wonderful for it.

This summer season has demonstrated how tough it can be to choose off the unfortunate badge when it gets to be constricting. Just take the circumstance of Lorde’s “Solar Power,” her very first single in four several years. As I mentioned prior to, Lorde’s occupation has manufactured several tunes about fleeting bliss this new music extends the custom, with her shaking off seasonal malaise (“I detest the winter season / cannot stand the cold”) and hitting the seashore. The sonic facts, cadences, and harmonies are difficult and ornate, as they often are for Lorde I compulsively replayed the track to acquire in the information. But the instrumentation of strummed guitar and congas evokes an era right before the moody zeitgeist Lorde herself served usher in. Appropriately, reactions have been really combined—with several longtime lovers complaining that “sad” Lorde is now “basic” Lorde.

Meanwhile, Lana Del Rey has entered her most uplifting, but complicated, chapter yet. As with Lorde, her catalog has prolonged marbled ecstasy with depressiveness, but Chemtrails Over the Country Club designed contentment central like by no means right before. The title observe describes “beautiful … deep normality” the beautiful opener, “White Gown,” relates recollections of emotion “like a god” as a 19-year-previous waitress. She adopted the album with a clutch of intriguing singles, including “Blue Banisters,” on which she ponders a friend’s information that “you can’t be a muse and be content, too.” The anthemic swoon of her previously catalog has been muted on most of these tracks: Del Rey now spins intricate, considerably cryptic narratives—I’m striving not to abuse the time period Dylanesque—that analyze serenity like an individual performing out a philosophical evidence.

Eilish, although happier than at any time, is carving a center lane—between Lorde’s cheerfulness, which some persons dismiss as corny, and Del Rey’s dizzying inner voyages. If inspiration can be observed in her new function, it is in the poise and care she shows though puzzling about how to share her thoughts with no obtaining them applied in opposition to her. Tiny bits of therapeutic wisdom do peek out way too. On the poignant “Male Fantasy,” Eilish talks about drifting aside from a close friend she thought she’d have for existence, and she’s not accurately despondent about the loss. “Nothing lasts,” she sings. “I know the deal.” Which is not a sunny thought—but it is however a person that can fight off darkness.